The Witcher Season 4 has sparked widespread discussion following the release of early reviews. Following Henry Cavill’s exit as Geralt of Rivia, anticipation was high to see how Liam Hemsworth would approach the iconic role. Initial responses suggest a largely positive reception to his performance, but opinions remain divided on the show’s storytelling.
The Witcher Season 4 reviews are in
The highly anticipated fourth season of The Witcher has finally arrived on Netflix, marking Liam Hemsworth’s debut as Geralt of Rivia. Picking up after the events of the third installment, Season 4 follows Geralt, Ciri, and Yennefer on separate paths as they face new allies and enemies.
Here’s what critics are saying about The Witcher Season 4 in their first reactions.
Aramide Tinubu of Variety wrote that “most fans of the show have likely been bracing themselves to see how Hemsworth takes on a character Cavill has long mastered.” She noted that while the voice is not “quite the same,” the transition becomes “mostly seamless” as the season progresses. Tinubu added that “even as a brand-new lead takes the charge, The Witcher Season 4 has mostly reclaimed its magic.”
Meanwhile, Times Now described Hemsworth’s portrayal as a “solid performance,” capturing both Geralt’s tough exterior and emotions. The outlet also called the new season “a visually stunning, action-packed continuation of the saga.” They added that the storytelling and direction make it “a must-watch for longtime fans and newcomers alike.”
Carly Lane from Collider states that although Hemsworth stepped into a role “that wasn’t originally his,” he manages to make it his own across eight episodes. She further highlighted Anya Chalotra’s Yennefer and Freya Allan’s Ciri for their strong performances. Lane noted that Season 4 proves the series “has become about more than just one character.”
However, not all feedback was positive. Slash Film described The Witcher Season 4 as a blend of “praiseworthy moments and monumental blunders.” The outlet states, “Season 4’s biggest problems lie in its poor understanding of Sapkowski’s work, which automatically invalidates any attempt to undermine canon or steer away from it.”
Meanwhile, What’s on Netflix critic Ashley Hurst described Liam Hemsworth’s performance as “admirable.” She praised him for “capturing both Geralt’s brutal side and emotional depth.” Hurst concluded with, “The Witcher remains a solid and entertaining enough fantasy show.”
